{ "status": "complete", "real_buildings": 8, "real_rows": [ { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84575-osm-67521488", "proposed_components": 1, "accepted_components": 1, "decisions": [ { "surface_index": 149, "area_m2": 208.21046350015268, "own_support": 1313, "own_strong_support": 1250, "own_mean_score": 0.9525314569473267, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 150, "area_m2": 155.0458804999832, "own_support": 835, "own_strong_support": 788, "own_mean_score": 0.9387801885604858, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 151, "area_m2": 223.12466150016817, "own_support": 1241, "own_strong_support": 1126, "own_mean_score": 0.9192009568214417, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 152, "area_m2": 101.60949449983178, "own_support": 584, "own_strong_support": 511, "own_mean_score": 0.8815166354179382, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 153, "area_m2": 2.872536999964254, "own_support": 14, "own_strong_support": 0, "own_mean_score": 0.03518995642662048, "action": "candidate_reassign_and_refit", "alternatives": [ { "anchor_surface": 152, "support": 4, "strong_support": 0, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.0, "eligible": false }, { "anchor_surface": 160, "support": 9, "strong_support": 7, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.4133791059085991, "eligible": true } ], "selected": { "anchor_surface": 160, "support": 9, "strong_support": 7, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.4133791059085991, "eligible": true }, "anchor_geometry": "reuse existing observation-fitted anchor exactly; seed refit used for evidence only", "extrapolation_uncertain": true, "reason": "more original roof-like observations agree with an adjacent supported plane; not target truth" }, { "surface_index": 154, "area_m2": 1.444721499991079, "own_support": 9, "own_strong_support": 0, "own_mean_score": 0.011472751386463642, "action": "uncertain_no_supported_replacement", "alternatives": [ { "anchor_surface": 160, "support": 3, "strong_support": 2, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.31214432034995815, "eligible": false } ] }, { "surface_index": 155, "area_m2": 8.390296999941237, "own_support": 43, "own_strong_support": 28, "own_mean_score": 0.7113750576972961, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 156, "area_m2": 0.9543255000074777, "own_support": 6, "own_strong_support": 0, "own_mean_score": 0.1296234130859375, "action": "uncertain_no_supported_replacement", "alternatives": [ { "anchor_surface": 157, "support": 3, "strong_support": 0, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.0, "eligible": false } ] }, { "surface_index": 157, "area_m2": 103.95930999954243, "own_support": 634, "own_strong_support": 581, "own_mean_score": 0.9269686341285706, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 158, "area_m2": 70.51795150037479, "own_support": 319, "own_strong_support": 241, "own_mean_score": 0.7917233109474182, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 159, "area_m2": 89.87276100022123, "own_support": 554, "own_strong_support": 510, "own_mean_score": 0.9249336123466492, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 160, "area_m2": 184.42366699987184, "own_support": 1029, "own_strong_support": 958, "own_mean_score": 0.9286758899688721, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 161, "area_m2": 309.55487249990506, "own_support": 1998, "own_strong_support": 1899, "own_mean_score": 0.9511880278587341, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] } ], "shell_before": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 910, "noded_unique_edges": 455, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 455, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_after": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 892, "noded_unique_edges": 446, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 446, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_diagnostic_passed": true, "candidate_is_accuracy_verified": false, "max_absolute_candidate_vertex_change_m": 10.29302300438927, "large_roof_preservation": [ { "source_surface": 149, "area_m2": 208.21046350015268, "max_height_change_m": 1.4210854715202004e-14 }, { "source_surface": 150, "area_m2": 155.0458804999832, "max_height_change_m": 8.597567102697212e-13 }, { "source_surface": 151, "area_m2": 223.12466150016817, "max_height_change_m": 1.0373923942097463e-12 }, { "source_surface": 152, "area_m2": 101.60949449983178, "max_height_change_m": 2.4158453015843406e-13 }, { "source_surface": 157, "area_m2": 103.95930999954243, "max_height_change_m": 1.4210854715202004e-14 }, { "source_surface": 160, "area_m2": 184.42366699987184, "max_height_change_m": 8.526512829121202e-14 }, { "source_surface": 161, "area_m2": 309.55487249990506, "max_height_change_m": 1.4210854715202004e-13 } ], "original_xyz_sha256": "68936c855e8e0697d5d399b6d4622d90ef8c9946d64a03cf7d55869e84f7da53", "original_xyz_unchanged": true, "point_deletion_change": 0, "caveat": "Same observations inform selection and fit. This is a development candidate, not an independent accuracy measurement." }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84595-osm-67521431", "proposed_components": 0, "accepted_components": 0, "decisions": [ { "surface_index": 9, "area_m2": 149.09357599984313, "own_support": 443, "own_strong_support": 372, "own_mean_score": 0.8563116788864136, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 10, "area_m2": 143.92538800004482, "own_support": 558, "own_strong_support": 544, "own_mean_score": 0.9697980880737305, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] } ], "shell_before": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 50, "noded_unique_edges": 25, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 25, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_after": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 50, "noded_unique_edges": 25, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 25, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_diagnostic_passed": true, "candidate_is_accuracy_verified": false, "max_absolute_candidate_vertex_change_m": 0, "large_roof_preservation": [ { "source_surface": 9, "area_m2": 149.09357599984313, "max_height_change_m": 0.0 }, { "source_surface": 10, "area_m2": 143.92538800004482, "max_height_change_m": 0.0 } ], "original_xyz_sha256": "72d96582843b9eb12568c9c2ec8ecff628517c7bc502d4ac839847fb7e31a226", "original_xyz_unchanged": true, "point_deletion_change": 0, "caveat": "Same observations inform selection and fit. This is a development candidate, not an independent accuracy measurement." }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row85199-osm-67521425", "proposed_components": 1, "accepted_components": 0, "decisions": [ { "surface_index": 41, "area_m2": 0.8824094999472234, "own_support": 2, "own_strong_support": 0, "own_mean_score": 0.5036423206329346, "action": "uncertain_no_supported_replacement", "alternatives": [ { "anchor_surface": 46, "support": 0, "strong_support": 0, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.0, "eligible": false } ] }, { "surface_index": 42, "area_m2": 2.1747145000904875, "own_support": 6, "own_strong_support": 0, "own_mean_score": 0.18785446882247925, "action": "uncertain_no_supported_replacement", "alternatives": [ { "anchor_surface": 44, "support": 0, "strong_support": 0, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.0, "eligible": false } ] }, { "surface_index": 43, "area_m2": 53.70983000009809, "own_support": 58, "own_strong_support": 11, "own_mean_score": 0.30922824144363403, "action": "uncertain_no_supported_replacement", "alternatives": [ { "anchor_surface": 44, "support": 0, "strong_support": 0, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.0, "eligible": false }, { "anchor_surface": 46, "support": 11, "strong_support": 8, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.12238324026521068, "eligible": false } ] }, { "surface_index": 44, "area_m2": 915.5844840006954, "own_support": 2818, "own_strong_support": 2681, "own_mean_score": 0.9018461108207703, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 45, "area_m2": 18.858426499829484, "own_support": 47, "own_strong_support": 2, "own_mean_score": 0.3005571663379669, "action": "candidate_reassign_and_refit", "alternatives": [ { "anchor_surface": 46, "support": 13, "strong_support": 9, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.47527034585964, "eligible": true } ], "selected": { "anchor_surface": 46, "support": 13, "strong_support": 9, "local_support_coverage_fraction": 0.47527034585964, "eligible": true }, "anchor_geometry": "reuse existing observation-fitted anchor exactly; seed refit used for evidence only", "extrapolation_uncertain": true, "reason": "more original roof-like observations agree with an adjacent supported plane; not target truth" }, { "surface_index": 46, "area_m2": 516.572082499854, "own_support": 1480, "own_strong_support": 1224, "own_mean_score": 0.8522211909294128, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] } ], "shell_before": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 246, "noded_unique_edges": 123, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 123, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_after": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 236, "noded_unique_edges": 118, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 3, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 115, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": false, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_diagnostic_passed": false, "candidate_is_accuracy_verified": false, "max_absolute_candidate_vertex_change_m": 8.016921570067055, "large_roof_preservation": [ { "source_surface": 44, "area_m2": 915.5844840006954, "max_height_change_m": 2.1316282072803006e-14 }, { "source_surface": 46, "area_m2": 516.572082499854, "max_height_change_m": 9.237055564881302e-14 } ], "original_xyz_sha256": "d2b792ae6584e6255a1dca8cf48560e9ca923bc56511d1cc63f2a362746c7ec6", "original_xyz_unchanged": true, "point_deletion_change": 0, "caveat": "Same observations inform selection and fit. This is a development candidate, not an independent accuracy measurement." }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84681-osm-67521385", "proposed_components": 0, "accepted_components": 0, "decisions": [ { "surface_index": 14, "area_m2": 44.03408249995861, "own_support": 268, "own_strong_support": 243, "own_mean_score": 0.91839599609375, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 15, "area_m2": 142.32330649943216, "own_support": 899, "own_strong_support": 836, "own_mean_score": 0.9270873069763184, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] } ], "shell_before": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 80, "noded_unique_edges": 40, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 40, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_after": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 80, "noded_unique_edges": 40, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 40, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_diagnostic_passed": true, "candidate_is_accuracy_verified": false, "max_absolute_candidate_vertex_change_m": 0, "large_roof_preservation": [ { "source_surface": 15, "area_m2": 142.32330649943216, "max_height_change_m": 0.0 } ], "original_xyz_sha256": "61b3de549cadbc53798b90692b84c901742e183458ce966b523f24f4bd6df6f8", "original_xyz_unchanged": true, "point_deletion_change": 0, "caveat": "Same observations inform selection and fit. This is a development candidate, not an independent accuracy measurement." }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84655-osm-67521498", "proposed_components": 0, "accepted_components": 0, "decisions": [ { "surface_index": 7, "area_m2": 14.83398399986961, "own_support": 51, "own_strong_support": 26, "own_mean_score": 0.6408500075340271, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 8, "area_m2": 16.30812349990437, "own_support": 57, "own_strong_support": 26, "own_mean_score": 0.6287961602210999, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] } ], "shell_before": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 38, "noded_unique_edges": 19, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 19, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_after": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 38, "noded_unique_edges": 19, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 19, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_diagnostic_passed": true, "candidate_is_accuracy_verified": false, "max_absolute_candidate_vertex_change_m": 0, "large_roof_preservation": [], "original_xyz_sha256": "d7a8c5639c6cb771bea05b5132afd9c8c22b2e1899c198888be1b9a05d20d684", "original_xyz_unchanged": true, "point_deletion_change": 0, "caveat": "Same observations inform selection and fit. This is a development candidate, not an independent accuracy measurement." }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84674-osm-67521381", "proposed_components": 0, "accepted_components": 0, "decisions": [ { "surface_index": 9, "area_m2": 45.081445999857486, "own_support": 166, "own_strong_support": 165, "own_mean_score": 0.9789015054702759, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 10, "area_m2": 45.60591200000222, "own_support": 160, "own_strong_support": 136, "own_mean_score": 0.8786131739616394, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] } ], "shell_before": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 50, "noded_unique_edges": 25, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 25, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_after": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 50, "noded_unique_edges": 25, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 25, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_diagnostic_passed": true, "candidate_is_accuracy_verified": false, "max_absolute_candidate_vertex_change_m": 0, "large_roof_preservation": [], "original_xyz_sha256": "b4bae17557a4845b84c1a70550c3445fb484c852cdb79789efb9d2dee5c6b1ae", "original_xyz_unchanged": true, "point_deletion_change": 0, "caveat": "Same observations inform selection and fit. This is a development candidate, not an independent accuracy measurement." }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84898-osm-66347628", "proposed_components": 0, "accepted_components": 0, "decisions": [ { "surface_index": 7, "area_m2": 26.35089100014966, "own_support": 58, "own_strong_support": 33, "own_mean_score": 0.6304900050163269, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 8, "area_m2": 26.460043499969558, "own_support": 81, "own_strong_support": 44, "own_mean_score": 0.6184895038604736, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] } ], "shell_before": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 38, "noded_unique_edges": 19, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 19, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_after": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 38, "noded_unique_edges": 19, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 19, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_diagnostic_passed": true, "candidate_is_accuracy_verified": false, "max_absolute_candidate_vertex_change_m": 0, "large_roof_preservation": [], "original_xyz_sha256": "ef6d50ef0be24d830fe91e14bbd453fa6a1c2e6c15913eadbc7ef1eac9cf7be8", "original_xyz_unchanged": true, "point_deletion_change": 0, "caveat": "Same observations inform selection and fit. This is a development candidate, not an independent accuracy measurement." }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84764-osm-67528254", "proposed_components": 0, "accepted_components": 0, "decisions": [ { "surface_index": 12, "area_m2": 0.1939349999849923, "own_support": 3, "own_strong_support": 0, "own_mean_score": 0.35991743206977844, "action": "uncertain_no_supported_replacement", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 13, "area_m2": 80.71587149996941, "own_support": 270, "own_strong_support": 245, "own_mean_score": 0.8715131878852844, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] }, { "surface_index": 14, "area_m2": 87.9066659999343, "own_support": 221, "own_strong_support": 88, "own_mean_score": 0.47626233100891113, "action": "keep", "alternatives": [] } ], "shell_before": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 70, "noded_unique_edges": 35, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 35, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_after": { "edge_tolerance_m": 0.001, "raw_ring_edges": 70, "noded_unique_edges": 35, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "edges_with_two_incidences": 35, "all_edges_have_two_incidences": true, "degenerate_edges_discarded": 0 }, "shell_diagnostic_passed": true, "candidate_is_accuracy_verified": false, "max_absolute_candidate_vertex_change_m": 0, "large_roof_preservation": [], "original_xyz_sha256": "1816daff578ca456112055946b02ec9e383dbee1eb6c124963faeadccb7b74c3", "original_xyz_unchanged": true, "point_deletion_change": 0, "caveat": "Same observations inform selection and fit. This is a development candidate, not an independent accuracy measurement." } ], "controlled_summary": [ { "case": "clean_step", "n": 6, "raw_mae_m": 5.294530246323525e-16, "methods": { "geometry": { "mae_m": 5.294530246323525e-16, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 }, "frozen_DL": { "mae_m": 5.294530246323525e-16, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 } } }, { "case": "real_raised_detail", "n": 6, "raw_mae_m": 5.294530246323525e-16, "methods": { "geometry": { "mae_m": 5.294530246323525e-16, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 }, "frozen_DL": { "mae_m": 5.294530246323525e-16, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 } } }, { "case": "real_depressed_detail", "n": 6, "raw_mae_m": 5.321669031369918e-16, "methods": { "geometry": { "mae_m": 5.321669031369918e-16, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 }, "frozen_DL": { "mae_m": 5.321669031369918e-16, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 } } }, { "case": "model_bump", "n": 6, "raw_mae_m": 0.2000000000000005, "methods": { "geometry": { "mae_m": 6.2345190738394905e-16, "changed_components": 6, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 }, "frozen_DL": { "mae_m": 6.2345190738394905e-16, "changed_components": 6, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 } } }, { "case": "model_dip", "n": 6, "raw_mae_m": 0.20000000000000048, "methods": { "geometry": { "mae_m": 6.2345190738394905e-16, "changed_components": 6, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 }, "frozen_DL": { "mae_m": 6.2345190738394905e-16, "changed_components": 6, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 } } }, { "case": "scattered_high", "n": 6, "raw_mae_m": 0.2000000000000005, "methods": { "geometry": { "mae_m": 0.2000000000000005, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 }, "frozen_DL": { "mae_m": 6.2345190738394905e-16, "changed_components": 6, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 } } }, { "case": "coherent_canopy", "n": 6, "raw_mae_m": 0.2000000000000005, "methods": { "geometry": { "mae_m": 0.2000000000000005, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 }, "frozen_DL": { "mae_m": 0.2000000000000005, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 } } }, { "case": "complete_occlusion", "n": 6, "raw_mae_m": 0.2000000000000005, "methods": { "geometry": { "mae_m": 0.2000000000000005, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 }, "frozen_DL": { "mae_m": 0.2000000000000005, "changed_components": 0, "harmed_over_2cm": 0 } } } ], "proposed_components": 2, "accepted_components": 1, "all_original_xyz_unchanged": true, "new_training": false, "independent_US_GT": false, "optical_boundary_confirmation_implemented": false, "complete_occlusion_completion_implemented": false, "source_code_sha256": "c5dece23c001a986f05676fe185ab5c8417b5f5c794436a2ead01d7036ffa33b" }