{ "status": "complete", "requested_buildings": 8, "methods": [ "baseline", "point_first", "guarded" ], "calibration": { "source_validation_roof_count": 41487, "source_validation_vegetation_count": 84088, "roof_removal_budget": 207, "base_roof_removed": 177, "point_override_threshold": 0.9894616007804871, "comparison": "strict greater-than", "composite_roof_removed": 207, "composite_roof_retention": 0.9950104852122351, "composite_vegetation_rejection": 0.44756683474455333, "target_labels_used": false, "target_accuracy_claim": false, "plane_protection_can_only_reduce_removal": true }, "threshold_audit": [ { "model": "point", "threshold": 0.7, "source_roof_rejection": 0.049075614047774004, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.6304704595185996, "target_flagged": 3033 }, { "model": "point", "threshold": 0.8, "source_roof_rejection": 0.035818449152746644, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.5211801921796213, "target_flagged": 2606 }, { "model": "point", "threshold": 0.9, "source_roof_rejection": 0.02145250319377154, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.36333365046142135, "target_flagged": 1985 }, { "model": "point", "threshold": 0.93, "source_roof_rejection": 0.015378311278231735, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.29400152221482256, "target_flagged": 1678 }, { "model": "point", "threshold": 0.98, "source_roof_rejection": 0.003205823510979343, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.10395062315669298, "target_flagged": 802 }, { "model": "image", "threshold": 0.7, "source_roof_rejection": 0.021524815002289872, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.7673746551232042, "target_flagged": 1160 }, { "model": "image", "threshold": 0.8, "source_roof_rejection": 0.011208330320341311, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.705665493292741, "target_flagged": 1006 }, { "model": "image", "threshold": 0.9, "source_roof_rejection": 0.006146503724058138, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.6028208543430692, "target_flagged": 733 }, { "model": "image", "threshold": 0.93, "source_roof_rejection": 0.004941306915419288, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.5542170107506422, "target_flagged": 512 }, { "model": "image", "threshold": 0.98, "source_roof_rejection": 0.0012293007448116277, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.31318380743982493, "target_flagged": 0 }, { "model": "fusion", "threshold": 0.7, "source_roof_rejection": 0.012726878299226264, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.7719412995909047, "target_flagged": 607 }, { "model": "fusion", "threshold": 0.8, "source_roof_rejection": 0.009472846915901367, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.700373418323661, "target_flagged": 451 }, { "model": "fusion", "threshold": 0.9, "source_roof_rejection": 0.006098295851712584, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.5705213585767291, "target_flagged": 215 }, { "model": "fusion", "threshold": 0.93, "source_roof_rejection": 0.004627955745173187, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.5070759204642755, "target_flagged": 137 }, { "model": "fusion", "threshold": 0.98, "source_roof_rejection": 0.0008918456383927495, "source_vegetation_rejection": 0.2836076491294834, "target_flagged": 22 } ], "paper_algorithm_reproduced": false, "new_training": false, "independent_target_GT": false, "missing_roof_completion": false, "rows": [ { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84575-osm-67521488", "original_points": 11321, "old_removed": 38, "point_98_flagged": 444, "high_fusion_but_disagreement_retained": 0, "point_overrides_proposed": 195, "point_overrides_protected": 3, "point_overrides_accepted": 192, "guarded_removed": 230, "disagreement_retained": 4829, "observed_planes": 11, "methods": { "point_first": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84575-osm-67521488", "method": "point_first", "input_points": 10877, "final_points": 10877, "removed_points": 444, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 13, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 2, "maximum_roof_z_m": 72.509, "maximum_roof_height_m": 26.718999084472657 }, "guarded": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84575-osm-67521488", "method": "guarded", "input_points": 11091, "final_points": 11091, "removed_points": 230, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 13, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 2, "maximum_roof_z_m": 72.503, "maximum_roof_height_m": 26.712999084472656 }, "baseline": { "removed_points": 38, "final_points": 11283, "roof_surfaces": 13, "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 2, "maximum_roof_z_m": 72.637, "maximum_roof_height_m": 26.846999084472657 } } }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84595-osm-67521431", "original_points": 1280, "old_removed": 79, "point_98_flagged": 79, "high_fusion_but_disagreement_retained": 1, "point_overrides_proposed": 24, "point_overrides_protected": 0, "point_overrides_accepted": 24, "guarded_removed": 103, "disagreement_retained": 307, "observed_planes": 2, "methods": { "point_first": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84595-osm-67521431", "method": "point_first", "input_points": 1201, "final_points": 1201, "removed_points": 79, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 2, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 65.391, "maximum_roof_height_m": 12.451001373291021 }, "guarded": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84595-osm-67521431", "method": "guarded", "input_points": 1177, "final_points": 1177, "removed_points": 103, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 2, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 65.392, "maximum_roof_height_m": 12.452001373291012 }, "baseline": { "removed_points": 79, "final_points": 1201, "roof_surfaces": 2, "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 65.39, "maximum_roof_height_m": 12.450001373291016 } } }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row85199-osm-67521425", "original_points": 5400, "old_removed": 0, "point_98_flagged": 8, "high_fusion_but_disagreement_retained": 0, "point_overrides_proposed": 0, "point_overrides_protected": 0, "point_overrides_accepted": 0, "guarded_removed": 0, "disagreement_retained": 921, "observed_planes": 7, "methods": { "point_first": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row85199-osm-67521425", "method": "point_first", "input_points": 5392, "final_points": 5392, "removed_points": 8, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 5, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 2, "maximum_roof_z_m": 56.851, "maximum_roof_height_m": 14.28100030517578 }, "guarded": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row85199-osm-67521425", "method": "guarded", "input_points": 5400, "final_points": 5400, "removed_points": 0, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 6, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 2, "maximum_roof_z_m": 62.300000000000004, "maximum_roof_height_m": 19.730000305175786 }, "baseline": { "removed_points": 0, "final_points": 5400, "roof_surfaces": 6, "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 2, "maximum_roof_z_m": 62.300000000000004, "maximum_roof_height_m": 19.730000305175786 } } }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84681-osm-67521385", "original_points": 1793, "old_removed": 3, "point_98_flagged": 25, "high_fusion_but_disagreement_retained": 0, "point_overrides_proposed": 9, "point_overrides_protected": 1, "point_overrides_accepted": 8, "guarded_removed": 11, "disagreement_retained": 770, "observed_planes": 2, "methods": { "point_first": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84681-osm-67521385", "method": "point_first", "input_points": 1768, "final_points": 1768, "removed_points": 25, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 4, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 2, "maximum_roof_z_m": 72.589, "maximum_roof_height_m": 21.708998931884764 }, "guarded": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84681-osm-67521385", "method": "guarded", "input_points": 1782, "final_points": 1782, "removed_points": 11, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 2, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 65.134, "maximum_roof_height_m": 14.253998931884766 }, "baseline": { "removed_points": 3, "final_points": 1790, "roof_surfaces": 5, "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 1, "maximum_roof_z_m": 73.169, "maximum_roof_height_m": 22.288998931884763 } } }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84655-osm-67521498", "original_points": 114, "old_removed": 0, "point_98_flagged": 0, "high_fusion_but_disagreement_retained": 0, "point_overrides_proposed": 0, "point_overrides_protected": 0, "point_overrides_accepted": 0, "guarded_removed": 0, "disagreement_retained": 77, "observed_planes": 0, "methods": { "point_first": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84655-osm-67521498", "method": "point_first", "input_points": 114, "final_points": 114, "removed_points": 0, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 2, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 59.844, "maximum_roof_height_m": 4.553999084472657 }, "guarded": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84655-osm-67521498", "method": "guarded", "input_points": 114, "final_points": 114, "removed_points": 0, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 2, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 59.844, "maximum_roof_height_m": 4.553999084472657 }, "baseline": { "removed_points": 0, "final_points": 114, "roof_surfaces": 2, "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 59.844, "maximum_roof_height_m": 4.553999084472657 } } }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84674-osm-67521381", "original_points": 362, "old_removed": 0, "point_98_flagged": 0, "high_fusion_but_disagreement_retained": 0, "point_overrides_proposed": 0, "point_overrides_protected": 0, "point_overrides_accepted": 0, "guarded_removed": 0, "disagreement_retained": 106, "observed_planes": 2, "methods": { "point_first": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84674-osm-67521381", "method": "point_first", "input_points": 362, "final_points": 362, "removed_points": 0, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 2, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 66.404, "maximum_roof_height_m": 15.554001525878903 }, "guarded": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84674-osm-67521381", "method": "guarded", "input_points": 362, "final_points": 362, "removed_points": 0, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 2, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 66.404, "maximum_roof_height_m": 15.554001525878903 }, "baseline": { "removed_points": 0, "final_points": 362, "roof_surfaces": 2, "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 66.404, "maximum_roof_height_m": 15.554001525878903 } } }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84898-osm-66347628", "original_points": 249, "old_removed": 6, "point_98_flagged": 31, "high_fusion_but_disagreement_retained": 0, "point_overrides_proposed": 10, "point_overrides_protected": 0, "point_overrides_accepted": 10, "guarded_removed": 16, "disagreement_retained": 129, "observed_planes": 2, "methods": { "point_first": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84898-osm-66347628", "method": "point_first", "input_points": 218, "final_points": 218, "removed_points": 31, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 2, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 57.771, "maximum_roof_height_m": 4.43099984741211 }, "guarded": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84898-osm-66347628", "method": "guarded", "input_points": 233, "final_points": 233, "removed_points": 16, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 2, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 57.773, "maximum_roof_height_m": 4.432999847412113 }, "baseline": { "removed_points": 6, "final_points": 243, "roof_surfaces": 3, "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 78.929, "maximum_roof_height_m": 25.58899984741211 } } }, { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84764-osm-67528254", "original_points": 864, "old_removed": 10, "point_98_flagged": 215, "high_fusion_but_disagreement_retained": 0, "point_overrides_proposed": 141, "point_overrides_protected": 1, "point_overrides_accepted": 140, "guarded_removed": 150, "disagreement_retained": 701, "observed_planes": 2, "methods": { "point_first": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84764-osm-67528254", "method": "point_first", "input_points": 649, "final_points": 649, "removed_points": 215, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 3, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 0, "maximum_roof_z_m": 59.292, "maximum_roof_height_m": 8.722000305175783 }, "guarded": { "id": "usbf-v1-dc-row84764-osm-67528254", "method": "guarded", "input_points": 714, "final_points": 714, "removed_points": 150, "native_lod2": true, "shell_diagnostic": true, "roof_surfaces": 3, "boundary_edges": 0, "nonmanifold_edges": 0, "orientation_inconsistent_edges": 0, "post_trim_points": 0, "selected_stage": "initial", "review_decision": "retain", "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 1, "maximum_roof_z_m": 59.045, "maximum_roof_height_m": 8.475000305175783 }, "baseline": { "removed_points": 10, "final_points": 854, "roof_surfaces": 3, "unresolved_roof_surfaces": 1, "maximum_roof_z_m": 68.608, "maximum_roof_height_m": 18.038000305175785 } } } ], "group_labels": { "baseline": "旧版 · 联合筛点", "point_first": "流程 B · 点云先重建", "guarded": "修订 · 强点云证据＋平面保护" }, "totals": { "baseline": 136, "point_first": 802, "guarded": 510 } }